Bentley HAMMER CONNECT Edition Help

Impacts of Transients

Hydraulic transients can result in the following physical phenomena.

High or low transient pressures—These can be applied to piping and joints in a fraction of a second and they often alternate from high to low and vice versa. High pressures resulting from the collapse of vapor pockets are analogous to cavitation in a pump: they primarily accelerate wear and tear, but they can burst a pipe by overcoming its surge-tolerance limit. Subatmospheric or even full-vacuum pressures can combine with overburden and groundwater pressures to collapse pipes by buckling failure. Groundwater can also be sucked into the piping.

High transient flows—These can result in significant degradation of water quality as deposits and rust are loosened and entrained at high velocities. This is aggravated whenever flows reverse direction during a transient event. High-velocity flows also exert forces at pipe bends.

Transient forces—Rapidly moving pressure pulses result in temporary, but very significant, transient forces at bends and other fittings, which can cause joints to move. Even for buried pipe, repeated deflections combined with pressure cycling can wear out joints and result in leakage or outright failure. Thrust blocks are typically sized for steady-state forces plus a safety factor—not transient forces—and typically resist thrust in only one direction. In pump stations, low pressures on the downstream side of a slow-closing check valve may result in a very fast closure known as valve slam. A 10 psi (69 kPa) pressure differential across the face of a 16 in. (400 mm) valve can result in impact forces in excess of 2,000 lb. (8,900 N).

Column separation—Water columns typically separate at abrupt changes in profile or local high points due to subatmospheric pressure. The space between the water columns is filled either by the formation of vapor (e.g., steam at ambient temperature) or air, if it is admitted to the pipeline through a valve. With vaporous cavitation, a vapor pocket forms and then collapses when the pipeline pressure increases as more flow enters the region than leaves it. Collapse of the vapor pocket can cause a dramatic high-pressure transient if the water column rejoins very rapidly, which can, in turn, cause the pipeline to rupture. Vaporous cavitation can also result in pipe flexure that damages pipe linings. High pressures can also result when air is expelled rapidly from a pipeline, which tends to repeat more times than when a vapor pocket collapses.

Vibrations—Rapid transient pressure fluctuations can result in vibrations or resonance that can cause even flanged pipes and fittings (bend and elbows) to dislodge, resulting in a leak or rupture. In fact, the cavitation that commonly occurs with water hammer can—as the phenomenon's name implies—release energy that sounds like someone pounding on the pipe with a hammer.

Hydraulic transient impacts can be expected at the following locations:

  • Check valves at pumps as flow reverses from the downstream reservoir to the pump.
  • Reservoir inlet valves, altitude valves at elevated tanks, or isolation valves if they close rapidly.
  • Local high points where vapor or air pockets collapse.
  • Dead ends as they reflect incoming pulses with up to double the wave amplitude.
  • Pipe bursts, where flow leaving the system may exceed the steady-state flow (in systems with high static head compared to the dynamic head).
  • Surge-control devices if not properly designed or operated.
  • Changes in pipeline profile or alignment where transient forces may be significant.

Hydraulic transient impacts can be expected to occur at the following times:

  • Pump startup before transient energy has decayed sufficiently or before all air has been removed from the line.
  • Pump emergency shutdown which may result in water-column separation and severe transient pressures due to vapor or air pocket formation and collapse.
  • Pump shifting during normal operations, which may result in frequent pressure shocks.

Environmental concerns due to hydraulic transients include:

  • Sewage spills or leaks to soils or groundwater during high transient pressures.
  • Drinking water contamination due to air, debris, or groundwater intrusion during subatmospheric pressures.

Hydraulic transients can result in the following infrastructure management issues and risks:

  • Premature aging and wear of valves, pipes, and pumps due to high magnitude and/or frequent pressure shocks.
  • Pump cavitation due to low suction head and pipe lining damage due to vacuum conditions.
  • Rapid pump or valve operation by major water users (e.g., a food production factory) may accelerate the pipe material and anchor fatigue in their vicinity.
  • Service interruptions due to repair and maintenance of infrastructure.